Ireland time
Nepal time
नेपाली
Nepal

Supreme Court to hear ex-police chief Karki's petition against removal on Wednesday

The Supreme Court will hold a preliminary hearing on Wednesday on former IGP Dan Bahadur Karki's petition challenging the Cabinet decision that removed him and made Manoj KC police chief, according to OnlineKhabar and The Kathmandu Post.

Illustration: Himalaya mountains and a Nepali temple roof
Nepal Ireland News illustration

The Supreme Court is scheduled to hold a preliminary hearing on Wednesday on a writ petition filed by former Inspector General of Police Dan Bahadur Karki, according to OnlineKhabar English and The Kathmandu Post.

On November 4, the government removed Karki as head of Nepal Police and named him security adviser to the prime minister. On the same day, Additional Inspector General Dr Manoj KC was promoted to inspector general. Karki registered his petition on November 6, arguing that the Cabinet decision was unlawful and had wronged him.

OnlineKhabar reports that the hearing was first fixed for November 16, after the Tihar holidays. It was postponed automatically when the government declared a public holiday for Chhath that day. After the court reopened on Tuesday, its administration set Wednesday for the preliminary hearing, which will be heard by a single-judge bench.

According to The Kathmandu Post, Karki is asking the court to overturn the Cabinet decisions on his removal and on KC's appointment. He also wants an interim order barring KC from exercising the powers of police chief until the final verdict. In addition, he seeks reinstatement for the rest of his tenure with his earlier status, salary, allowances and other benefits, and an order preventing his removal or transfer before the end of his term without lawful procedure.

The Post says Karki argues that he was removed before his term ended and that no legal provision allows a serving inspector general to be moved to a post outside the police. He says neither the Police Act 1955 nor the Police Regulations 2014 provides for this. He also says the government breached natural justice by not telling him the reasons or asking for his explanation, and that he learned of the decision from the media before receiving an official letter from the Home Ministry.

Karki cites two Supreme Court precedents. One concerns former police chief Achyut Krishna Kharel, who was removed in 1997, 36 days after taking office. The other concerns Hitendra Dev Shakya, a former executive director of the Nepal Electricity Authority, who was moved to the Water and Energy Commission. Karki also challenges the government's reliance on Section 9(2) of the Police Act, which leaves police tenure to the government's discretion.

The Post says the court may issue an interim order suspending the Cabinet decision, or it may ask the government for an explanation before deciding on interim relief. Wednesday's hearing will determine whether KC can keep exercising the inspector general's powers while the case continues.